Evaluation Scheme For
Design Engineering -2B (2160001) (6th Sem- Regular Student)
BE-III Year - All Branch
At the ensuing fourth semester examinations, the work of the students in Design
Engineering 1B is to be evaluated and the evaluation is to be out of 80 marks.
PROCESS OF EVALUATION:
A Viva-Voce examination will be conducted at the end of the
semester by a team of two examiners, one of whom will be an internal Faculty Member,
who may have taught the subject (Internal examiner must remain the same throughout the
entire of examination for batch). The other will be an external examiner to be appointed by
the University. (Please note that all the other practical and viva voce examinations at the
end of the 6
th semester will be conducted internally by the College/ Institute.)
Note:
1) Total Marks for the evaluation of practical examination: 80
2) Minimum passing marks: 40/80
3) Ratio of evaluation by internal/external examiner appointed: 50% in each sub-head
4) For preparation of the report, students shall follow the format provided by GTU.However, depending on the case, the content may be modified as the case may be.
5) Examiner essentially needs to evaluate the learning process of the student during the
semester, not only the final outcome. As outcome is important for any project but
during the student stage, projects are intended for practical learning and “Learning by
doing” is the Mantra for Design Engineering subject. (One should celebrate the failure
and learn from it to get success). So please evaluate the process properly with giving
sufficient time for each project.
6) Students need to explain all canvases/framework if any prepared in hard copy to
the panel of examiners (internal and external).
7) Power point presentation is not mandatory but desirable.
EVALUATION SCHEME:
1) Prototyping & Testing: (15 Marks)
- Versions of Prototypes with all possible modification and iterations to further refine the solutions (15 marks out of 25, for students who have made iterative versions for prototype with refinement; if students only present final prototype without any version/s or modification then this 15 marks will not be counted for such students)
- Note: Report should carry all details/modification for the versions of prototype with images, it is not required to have different physical models for the different versions
- All these iterative versions and its details with Testing/user feedback results (10 marks out of 25, if the details and testing/user feedback results are there)
2) Detail Design Calculation : (10 Marks)
- It may include size & shape specifications, tolerances, material requirement, standards/safety rules/govt. policies, sketches, detail & assembly drawings, list of components with specifications etc.) These all aspects are case sensitive so one can add/remove some aspects from the list. (For CE, IT, other process related branches, one may also use Flow chart/Block Diagrams/Algorithms/Programming etc.)
- Modelling, Simulation and Analysis (Software modelling), Mathematical model
3)Design for Use, Reuse and Sustainability: (10 Marks)
- Design for USE – How long this design will work?
o Maintainability
- Design for Reuse
- Design for Sustainability
4) (10 Marks)
- Measuring Instruments/ techniques - knowledge and use, manufacturing/fabrication process, electronic circuit/boards, open source tool
- Comparison of existing materials, methods/process, technology, tools and equipment for the project
5) Video of Prototypes (YouTube link): (5 Marks)
6) Report & Log book: (15 Marks)
- Compilation of work, complete Log book, Future action plan, Question and Answer, Communication Skill
